IRC 1202 | Income Tax Exemption of Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS)

What is it? The Core Concept

Imagine building a successful business from the ground up. You invest your time, capital, and energy, and eventually, you sell it for a significant profit. Ordinarily, that profit would be subject to capital gains tax. Code Section 1202, however, provides a special carve-out, allowing you to keep a much larger share of those proceeds.

For stock acquired on or after September 28, 2010, the exclusion can be up to 100% of the gain. For stock acquired before that date, the exclusion percentages were lower (50% or 75%). This 100% exclusion is what makes Section 1202 particularly powerful today.

Why You Should Be Aware of It: The Power of Tax-Free Gains

The primary reason to be aware of Section 1202 is the immense tax savings it can provide. Consider this: without QSBS, a significant portion of your hard-earned capital gains from selling your business could be eaten up by federal capital gains taxes, plus potentially the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (“NIIT”). With QSBS, that could be zero.

This isn’t just about reducing your tax bill; it’s about maximizing the wealth you retain from your entrepreneurial endeavors. It fundamentally changes the economic equation of a business sale.

How It Can Be Helpful: Practical Benefits

1. Significant Tax Savings: This is the headline benefit. A 100% exclusion means no federal capital gains tax on eligible gains. This can result in literally millions of dollars in additional after-tax proceeds.
2. No Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) Impact: For stock acquired on or after September 28, 2010, the excluded gain is also not considered a preference item for AMT purposes. This is a crucial point, as AMT can often erode the benefits of other tax breaks.
3. Exemption from Net Investment Income Tax: The 3.8% NIIT, which applies to certain investment income for high-income earners, also does not apply to excluded QSBS gains.
4. Incentivizes Growth: The very existence of Section 1202 incentivizes both founders and investors to build and invest in small, growth-oriented companies, knowing there’s a potential tax-free exit down the road.
5. Per-Taxpayer Limitation: The gain exclusion is limited to the greater of $10 million or 10 times the adjusted basis of the stock sold by the taxpayer. Importantly, this limit applies per issuer and per taxpayer. This means that if you have multiple taxpayers (especially using trusts) or multiple qualified small businesses, you could potentially claim multiple exclusions. Furthermore, with proper planning (e.g., gifting QSBS to family members), you can potentially “stack” these exclusions across multiple taxpayers, increasing the overall tax-free gain for a family.

Potential Pitfalls to Avoid: The Strict Requirements AND Potential Inapplicability

While incredibly beneficial, Section 1202 comes with a stringent set of requirements. Missing just one can disqualify your stock and cost you those significant tax savings. Here are the key pitfalls:

1. C Corporation Requirement: Only stock issued by a domestic C corporation can qualify as QSBS. If your business is an S corporation, LLC taxed as a partnership, or other pass-through entity, it cannot issue QSBS. This is a crucial initial decision for any startup. While you can convert to a C corporation, the QSBS clock generally starts when the C corporation stock is issued.
2. Original Issuance: The stock must be acquired by the taxpayer directly from the corporation at its original issuance. This typically means in exchange for money, other property (not stock), or as compensation for services. Purchasing stock from another shareholder on a secondary market will generally not qualify.
3. Gross Assets Test: At all times from the date of enactment of Code Section 1202 (August 10, 1993) up to and immediately after the stock issuance, the corporation’s aggregate gross assets (cash plus adjusted basis of other property) cannot exceed $50 million. This is a critical ongoing test. If the company crosses this threshold before your stock is issued, that stock will not qualify.
4. Active Business Requirement: During substantially all of the taxpayer’s holding period, the corporation must be engaged in an “active trade or business.” At least 80% of its assets must be used in the active conduct of one or more qualified businesses. Certain businesses are specifically excluded, including those primarily involving:
   
   • Professional services (health, law, engineering, accounting, consulting, etc.)
   • Banking, insurance, financing, leasing, or similar businesses
   • Farming
   • Hotels, motels, restaurants, or similar businesses
   • Mining operations
   • Any business where the principal asset is the reputation or skill of one or more employees.
5. Five-Year Holding Period: You must hold the QSBS for more than five years to qualify for the gain exclusion. This is a strict requirement, and selling even a day early will disqualify the gain.
6. No Significant Stock Redemptions: The corporation generally cannot have made significant redemptions of its stock (exceeding certain thresholds) within specific periods before or after the QSBS issuance. This prevents companies from simply buying back shares to manufacture QSBS.
7. Documentation: Poor recordkeeping is a common pitfall. You need clear documentation to prove all the requirements have been met, including the original issuance, the company’s asset values over time, and the active business activities.
8. Triple taxation: In addition, in some states, C corporations not only have to pay federal income taxes twice (double taxation), but there could be state income taxes on C corporations. Therefore, you need to be sure 1202 is right for you before pulling the trigger.
9. Asset sales: Importantly, many acquisitions are asset sales rather than equity sales. In the former case, 1202 does not apply because the equity is not acquired. In the latter case, 1202 may apply, but it is less common because most transactions. Typically, the buyer prefers to buy the assets instead of the equity for both tax and legal reasons.

Conclusion and Next Steps

Section 1202 is a golden opportunity for business owners, but it’s not a set-it-and-forget-it provision. It requires foresight, careful planning, and ongoing monitoring to ensure compliance. Before deciding on a c-corporation just for purposes of qualifying for Code Section 1202, consider the folowing:

• Consider entity choice carefully from day one. If a future sale is a possibility and you anticipate meeting the QSBS criteria, forming as a C corporation can set you up for success.
• Monitor your asset levels. Keep a close eye on your company’s aggregate gross assets to ensure they don’t exceed the $50 million limit at the time of stock issuance.
• Understand your business activity. Confirm that your business falls within the “qualified trade or business” definitions.
• Plan your holding period. Be mindful of the five-year holding period requirement before any potential sale.
• Document everything. Maintain meticulous records of stock issuances, asset valuations, and business activities.

This is a complex area of tax law, and the nuances can make all the difference. There are compelling reasons to try to qualify for Code Section 1202 treatment, but there are also compelling reasons that may discourage you from doing so. I strongly recommend we review your specific business structure, growth plans, and long-term objectives to determine if Code Section 1202 planning is appropriate for you and how best to implement it. Proactive planning can literally save you millions.

Author: